For parents, it’s tempting to pour a lot of thought into our kids’ holiday gifts. If we can just find the perfect educational toy or cultural experience, maybe our kids will become geniuses or earn soccer scholarships.
It doesn’t help when stores push “genius” toys and unforgettable experiences. But here’s what parents are forgetting: The more we try to optimize our kids’ holiday gifts, the more we miss out on the joy that’s available right now.
As a healthcare ethicist and mom of two kids, I have good news: Your child’s development does not depend on finding the perfect gifts. You can resist the urge to over-engineer and still do right by your family.
If you need a reset from the pressure to optimize this holiday season, here are four reframes to help lower the stakes, protect play for its own sake, and put presence ahead of performance.
1. There is no magic key
Endless reviews, algorithms, and AI tools make finding the perfect gift seem attainable. If we skip the hunt, it can feel like we didn’t try hard enough.
But when we zoom out, we see that this is just one of hundreds of parenting decisions we’ll make this year. The effects of a single small choice, like what to get for the holidays, will be outweighed by all the other things that influence our kids’ development and well-being. One gift won’t set a life trajectory.
So we can stop searching Amazon for the mythical gift that will magically unlock our children’s potential and give them a direct path to success. Unfortunately, there isn’t one.
2. More is not always better
Chasing the best can backfire if we think that “best” means fancy or high-tech. Research shows that when it comes to play, simple, classic toys often result in more quality play than more elaborate, scripted ones. Open-ended toys leave more room for imagination.
The extra we hope to squeeze from “perfect” usually isn’t in the product itself. It’s in how we show up. As Nicola Yelland, professor of early childhood studies at the University of Melbourne, notes: “Any toy can be educational when you play with your children and talk to them about what they are doing and learning.”
Instead of worrying about the perfect gift, we can focus our efforts on finding a good fit and then be present for it.
3. Support, don’t engineer
Wanting kids to learn and grow is good, but it’s easy to take this desire too far. When our gifts or enriching plans aim to upgrade skills and talents, play starts to feel like work, which can undermine the intrinsic value.
Experience gifts aren’t immune to concerted cultivation efforts either. Writer Faith Hill notes that even family travel now comes with growth goals. The hope is that a trip abroad will help our kids become more adaptive, resilient, and cultured. Productivity culture can sneak in anywhere.
When we stop treating every leisure moment as productive training, however, we can create more space for joy, curiosity, creativity, and connection — values that are worth pursuing for their own sake, not just as means to future achievement.
Instead of asking, “What might this help my child become?” we can ask, “What might this invite my child to notice, enjoy, or share right now?”
4. Love can be enough
Nothing we get our kids for the holidays will get them into Harvard. And that’s okay.
As developmental psychologist Alison Gopnik reminds us in her book “The Gardener and the Carpenter,” our job as parents is not to manufacture a particular kind of child or to shape their destiny, but to create a space of love, safety, and stability where they can flourish.
We don’t need to calculate which gifts will give our kids the greatest developmental payoff. The holidays are a chance to help our kids feel that they matter now. And if we can do that, it’s more than enough.
Jen Zamzow, PhD, is an adjunct professor of healthcare ethics at Concordia University Irvine, a writer, and a mom to two young boys. You can find her at her Substack newsletter “A Well-Lived Life.”
Want to give your kids the ultimate advantage? Sign up for CNBC’s new online course, How to Raise Financially Smart Kids. Learn how to build healthy financial habits today to set your children up for greater success in the future. Use coupon code EARLYBIRD for 30% off. Offer valid from Dec. 8 to Dec. 22, 2025. Terms apply.